Illustrated comparison of brown woodland bears in 2000 and the red and blue suburban bear families in 2025
EXHIBIT 001 · Then: woods and clouds. Now: school districts, suburbs, and suspicious prosperity. Artist’s reconstruction.

My son and I have developed a strange fascination with the Charmin commercials.

Not because we enjoy watching animated bears discuss the cleanliness of their assholes. Although Procter & Gamble seems convinced that's exactly what America wants.

We're interested in something more troubling.

What the hell is going on with these bears?

I've been watching them for over 25 years, and at some point somebody needs to start asking questions.

When they first appeared in 2000, the bears were brown. They lived in the woods. They had no visible means of employment, no plumbing, and very little understanding of basic personal hygiene.

They were bears.

Twenty-five years later, they're red and blue, driving cars, raising children in affluent suburban neighborhoods, and taking algebra.

That's quite a turnaround for a family that used to shit behind trees.

I'm not suggesting anything illegal happened.

I'm saying if five homeless woodland animals suddenly appear in a four-bedroom colonial with a three-car garage, I have questions about the down payment.

And the seller's disclosure.

The Original Brown Bears Have Disappeared

In 2007, Charmin introduced separate red and blue bears to represent its Ultra Strong and Ultra Soft products.

Fair enough.

Except nobody explained what happened to the brown ones.

Were they promoted? Relocated? Absorbed in a merger?

Did the red bears buy them out in a hostile acquisition?

Charmin's official explanation is that the colors represent different products.

That's perfectly reasonable. It also explains nothing about where the original family went.

Red and blue bears in a wealthy suburban driveway with a cub carrying an algebra book and a brown bear looking left out
EXHIBIT 006 · Artist’s reconstruction of the suspected bear families. Original brown-bear whereabouts remain unconfirmed.

From Shitting in the Woods to the Suburban Upper Class

The most disturbing development isn't the color change.

It's the money.

The bears have kitchens. Bedrooms. Modern bathrooms. Automobiles.

I assume there's an HOA, and I'd love to attend one of those meetings.

“Before we discuss the landscaping violation at 14 Maple Court, Mrs. Henderson has asked us to address the 900-pound red bear who keeps inspecting the neighborhood children's assholes.”

But where did the money come from?

I've worked in mortgages long enough to know that a family of bears with no discernible income should not qualify for a conventional loan on a $900,000 home.

Unless they're putting down considerably more than 20%.

The parents never appear to work. I've never seen Papa Bear leave for an office. Nobody is wearing a tie.

Or pants.

At the very least, I'd like to see two years of tax returns and a satisfactory letter of explanation for the gaps in their employment history.

“Borrower states he was residing in a wooded area from 2000 through 2007. No verifiable income. Assets consist of miscellaneous berries, fish, and approximately 600 rolls of toilet paper.”

That's going to underwriting.

They've also abandoned their earlier method of transportation, which was clouds. Now they drive cars. I don't know whether they lost cloud privileges or decided a Toyota Highlander was more practical for school drop-off.

Either way, it's another expense nobody can explain.

The Great Charmin Cirrus Buoyancy Collapse: illustrated cloud-filled mock scientific graph showing the red and blue bear families descending from their early cloud era toward SUVs and suburbia
EXHIBIT 0042 · The Great Charmin Cirrus Buoyancy Collapse. All measurements, altitudes, and findings are fictional; no bears, clouds, or actual scientists were consulted. View full-size chart ↗

The 2010 Charmin Bear Ass Scandal

Here's where things get genuinely interesting. And unlike the questions about their real estate holdings, this part actually happened.

In 2010, Kimberly-Clark — the company behind Cottonelle — challenged claims made in Charmin commercials. The matter went before the National Advertising Division, an industry watchdog.

The problem? The commercials showed bears with pieces of toilet paper stuck to their backsides. After using Charmin, the bears appeared completely clean.

But Charmin had only claimed its product left fewer pieces behind.

Not zero.

Fewer.

The watchdog determined that the animation exaggerated the results and recommended Charmin change its advertising.

Which means that somewhere in America, educated professionals were assembled to determine whether an imaginary bear's asshole was sufficiently dirty to comply with advertising standards.

There were meetings. There were documents. Somebody opened a PowerPoint.

“Good morning, everyone. If you turn to slide seven, you'll notice the bear's asshole is completely clean. As you can see, this presents a significant substantiation problem.”

Imagine explaining that day to your spouse.

“How was work, honey?”

“Long.”

“Anything interesting?”

“Well, we spent four hours arguing over whether a cartoon bear should have a little more toilet paper stuck to his ass.”

“Did you win?”

“We got a partial concession.”

“Your father would be proud.”

And note who brought the challenge: not an animal welfare organization, not a concerned parent. A competing toilet paper manufacturer.

For a brief period in 2010, the nation's toilet paper makers were locked in a bitter dispute over who was allowed to depict the cleanest fictional bear anus.

And we survived it.

Somehow.

The Red and Blue Bears Enter Politics

In 2012, Charmin held an actual toilet paper election — Ultra Soft versus Ultra Strong, blue versus red, with campaign events in Flushing, New York.

Flushing.

The brown bears were not on the ballot.

They founded this whole operation, and now they're disenfranchised?

That's not marketing.

That's witness elimination.

The Bears Are Becoming Too Intelligent

In 2013, one of the cubs appeared in a commercial holding a copy of Franz Kafka's The Metamorphosis.

That's true.

For anyone unfamiliar, the book is about a man who wakes up one morning to discover he's transformed into an enormous insect.

Which is a remarkable literary selection for a young bear who has himself undergone an unexplained physical transformation.

That's not bathroom reading.

That's evidence.

The cub knows something happened to his family. He remembers being brown. And now he's searching existentialist literature for an explanation.

Meanwhile, a more recent commercial shows a bear cub in algebra class, solving for X — twenty-five years after his ancestors dragged their asses across tree stumps.

I don't remember “backsides” coming up on my SATs.

Although it might explain my math score.

My Final Questions for Procter & Gamble

Where are the original brown bears?

How did the surviving families accumulate enough wealth to purchase upscale suburban real estate?

And why is every member of this family so extraordinarily interested in everybody else's asshole?

I've lived with my wife and son for years. We have a perfectly functional bathroom. Approximately zero percent of our family conversations involve gathering in a circle to celebrate the condition of one another's backsides.

Apparently we're missing an important bonding experience.

Maybe I'm overthinking this. Maybe the original brown bears are perfectly happy somewhere, enjoying a quiet retirement far from the corporate empire they helped build.

I hope so. I'd like to think they're back in the woods, living as nature intended.

No algebra. No mortgage payments. No regulatory hearings requiring independent verification of how much toilet paper is stuck to their asses.

Just bears being bears.

Because after 25 years of investigating these creatures, I've come to one conclusion.

We used to ask whether a bear shits in the woods.

Now we have to ask whether he's been preapproved for a mortgage, which political party he supports, and why his third grader just got a B-minus in algebra.

We've made the bears human.

And from what I've seen of humanity lately, that seems like a pretty shitty thing to do to a bear.

The Jug Handle will continue to monitor the situation. Anyone with information concerning the whereabouts of the original brown bears is encouraged to contact our investigative desk. Please do not send photographs of your ass.